The creative cliff: why later ideas surprise

The first ideas are often the most familiar, not necessarily the best. Keep exploring beyond the obvious answers, then judge the alternatives against the problem and the evidence.

Build & Validate
Evidence-led buildingExperimentation

Adapted by the EWOR Team from an article on EWOR (opens in a new tab)2 min read

Stay with the question after the easy answers

The first workable idea is often the easiest to picture, which makes it tempting to settle on it. But familiar ideas are not always the strongest ones. Before committing to a favourite, keep exploring long enough to see what other approaches might be possible.

Research by Brian J. Lucas and Loran F. Nordgren, published in 2020, examined what they called the creative cliff illusion. In their idea-generation tasks, participants expected creativity to decline more sharply than subsequent evaluations suggested it did. In other words, the point at which generating ideas starts to feel harder is not necessarily the point at which useful ideas stop emerging. That does not mean later ideas are always better, but it is a reason not to stop too early.

Make room for divergence

Start with a specific challenge and ask everyone to write down possible solutions before discussing or evaluating them. Keep each idea concise, and resist the urge to reject suggestions as soon as they seem impractical. An idea that looks weak on its own may reveal something useful when compared with other approaches.

Give the exercise a time limit or a clear idea target so the group keeps going after the obvious answers have surfaced. Adjust the exercise to the question at hand: a small operational decision may need only a short session, while a broader strategic challenge may benefit from more exploration. If ideas start to repeat, change the angle. Consider a different customer perspective, a different constraint or an alternative way to define the problem.

Keep safety, legal and ethical boundaries clear throughout. The aim is to postpone premature judgement, not to ignore constraints that genuinely rule out an approach.

Evaluate ideas against the Problem

Start with a specific challenge and ask everyone to write down possible solutions before discussing or evaluating them. Keep each idea concise, and resist the urge to reject suggestions as soon as they seem impractical. An idea that looks weak on its own may reveal something useful when compared with other approaches.

Give the exercise a time limit or a clear idea target so the group keeps going after the obvious answers have surfaced. Adjust the exercise to the question at hand: a small operational decision may need only a short session, while a broader strategic challenge may benefit from more exploration. If ideas start to repeat, change the angle. Consider a different customer perspective, a different constraint or an alternative way to define the problem.

Keep safety, legal and ethical boundaries clear throughout. The aim is to postpone premature judgement, not to ignore constraints that genuinely rule out an approach.

Source: EWOR article (opens in a new tab)

Get the next signal before everyone else.

Frameworks and contrarian theses for outlier founders, straight to your inbox. No fluff, no recycled advice, weekly.

The EWOR Signals newsletter