Real network effect or just growth?
A network effect only exists when participation makes the product more valuable to others. Find out who benefits, measure the change and understand what happens when key participants leave.
Adapted by the EWOR Team from Daniel Dippold’s article (opens in a new tab)3 min read
Name how parties make the product better and for whom
More registrations do not necessarily mean a product is becoming more valuable. The key question is whether active participation improves the experience for people already using it. Who benefits when someone new joins, and what becomes possible that was not possible before? EWOR’s CEO and co-founder, Daniel Dippold also highlights the other side of this dynamic. When valuable participants leave, the product can become less useful, giving others a reason to leave too.
Make the mechanism explicit in one sentence.
“When [participant type] joins and takes [action], [existing participant type] gains [specific benefit].”
This forces you to identify not just who is joining, but how their participation creates value for someone else. Without that connection, growth may reflect a successful acquisition strategy, a broader catalogue, improved purchasing terms or lower unit costs. Those can all be valuable advantages, but they are not, by themselves, evidence of a network effect. For example, a marketplace may need relevant supply in a particular location. Adding sellers elsewhere might increase the total account count without improving the experience for a buyer in that market.
Measure whether existing users actually benefit
Once you have defined the mechanism, decide how to tell whether it works. Choose an outcome that matters to existing users, such as how quickly they find a suitable match, how likely they are to receive a useful response or whether a transaction is completed. Compare these outcomes across cohorts or markets with different levels of relevant participation. Before concluding that the network is responsible for an improvement, account for other possible causes, including changes in product quality, marketing, pricing or user mix.
The number of accounts tells you how many people have signed up, not how much value they create. Track the participants who are active and the interactions that make the product more useful. Then look for where the effect stops working. Does each additional participant still improve the experience, or do congestion and low-quality contributions start to undermine it? Is the benefit shared across the user base, or does it only emerge within particular segments? Speak to users to understand what they value, then compare their accounts with their actual behaviour.
Build for the cold start and possibility of reversal
A network effect cannot help much if the first users arrive before there is enough participation to make the product useful. Identify the minimum level of activity needed to deliver a worthwhile first experience, and explain how you will provide that value before the network can sustain it. Next, examine how dependent that activity is on a small number of participants. If a few people generate most of the useful interactions, losing them could have a much greater impact than losing the same number of ordinary users. Consider, too, whether participants can use competing products at the same time and whether your proposed advantage remains meaningful when they do.
Choose an early warning measure that shows whether the product is becoming less valuable to the people who remain. For example, monitor whether departures lead to fewer useful matches or responses. If they do, the declining experience may prompt further departures and reinforce the initial loss. This is a risk to watch for, not an outcome to assume is inevitable.

No comments yet.
Be the first to comment on this signal.